Brussels Takes Austria and Seven Others to Task Over Pension Fund Taxes

Austria

The European Commission has opened legal proceedings against Austria and seven other EU countries, accusing them of giving their own pension funds and life insurers an unfair tax advantage, reported by News ORF.

Brussels announced on Thursday that the eight countries, Germany, Spain, Italy, Austria, Poland, Portugal, Romania and Belgium, may be breaking EU rules on the free movement of capital. At the heart of the case is a simple question: should a pension fund be treated differently just because it comes from another member state?

According to the Commission, national tax laws in these countries say yes. Domestic pension funds and life insurers are exempt from tax on their investment income. Comparable funds and insurers from other EU or European Economic Area countries, however, are taxed on the same earnings.

There is a second gap. Foreign providers are not allowed to set aside reserves to cover what they will owe customers in the future. Domestic companies can deduct those reserves from their taxable income, which lowers their bills and gives them a clear edge.

The Commission says this matters far beyond the world of tax lawyers. Cross-border investment by pension funds and life insurers helps European capital markets run smoothly, strengthens the competitiveness of European companies and helps secure the retirement incomes of ordinary citizens. When countries protect their own providers, that flow of money is held back.

The next step is a set of formal letters of notice, which the Commission plans to send to all eight governments. Each country now has two months to reply and fix the problems Brussels has identified.

If the answers do not satisfy the Commission, it can move the case forward by issuing a reasoned opinion, the next stage in the infringement process.

For now, the message from Brussels is firm but not final: in a single European market, the rules should be the same for everyone, wherever a pension fund calls home.